Goodbye driver experience, hello ‘journey experience’: exploring the passenger experience in autonomous vehicles for MaaS applications

A blog by Neil McGregor – Chief Engineer, Steel E-Motive project

Autonomous vehicles are going to be a game changer for the automotive industry. They will unlock new possibilities for the Mobility as a Service (MaaS) industry and transform the movement of people and goods. Perhaps more importantly, they are going to completely change what we expect in the passenger experience. Self-driving vehicles remove an element of trust and confidence – the driver – and this can be an emotional journey for the uninitiated. Remove the driver controls, and suddenly the image of the average passenger car looks completely different and understandably inspires anxiety for some.

Passenger experience in an autonomous vehicle

The transformation to MaaS poses two significant challenges which will have an affect on how consumers feel about their user experience:

  • ensuring that new design freedoms don’t compromise vehicle safety
  • developing positive passenger experience based on their user expectations

The Steel E-Motive program is developing two fully autonomous electric vehicle concepts – an urban and an extra-urban variant. In both of these vehicle variants, we will be addressing these challenges based on our research into passenger expectations for their experience in autonomous vehicles.

This blog explores some of our findings on the consumer expectations of the autonomous vehicle experience and how we are aligning these with our design considerations for the Steel E-Motive vehicle concepts to ensure a positive passenger experience in autonomous vehicles.

What will it be like to sit in an autonomous vehicle for MaaS applications?

Our studies into consumer expectations for level 5 autonomous vehicles show that there will be a fundamental shift in the primary customer requirements and experience expectations. Imagine getting into a car with no driver controls. No steering wheel, no pedals, no driver’s seat. A fully autonomous vehicle completely removes the need for a driver which means that everyone inside the cabin is now a passenger along for the journey. Suddenly there is no driver experience but a ‘journey experience’.  It’s like stepping onto a bus or train, but in a much more compact and intimate setting.

Levels of Vehicle Autonomy

There are six levels of vehicle automation, as published by SAE International, to describe the amount of driver intervention required when a vehicle is in motion. The Steel E-Motive vehicle concepts are targeting level 5 vehicle autonomy.

Level 0 vehicle autonomy

Level 0

The driver has complete control over the vehicle and its functions. No driver assistance.

Level 1 vehicle autonomy

Level 1

The driver is primarily in control of the vehicle with some assistance functions eg. adaptive cruise control

Level 2 vehicle autonomy

Level 2

The driver must keep their hands on the wheel, but the system can assist in controlling speed and steering.

Level 3 vehicle autonomy

Level 3

Vehicles can drive themselves under a few ideal conditions, but a human driver is still required behind the wheel for when conditions change.

Level 4 vehicle autonomy

Level 4

Vehicles can drive themselves without human interaction under specific use cases and conditions. A human may need to step in for some driving modes.

Level 5 vehicle autonomy

Level 5

Completely autonomous driving without the need for human interaction. The Steel E-Motive program is targeting this level of vehicle autonomy.

Removing the driver interface opens new possibilities to explore how we can tailor the interior for a positive passenger experience in autonomous vehicles. We anticipate that vehicle occupants will spend their journey time very differently. Where once they might be operating the vehicle or concentrating on the road, passengers are now able to work and socialise either directly or virtually. Or they can just sit back and enjoy the ride.

Alternative interior layouts are being considered for both the urban and the extra-urban variant of the Steel E-Motive vehicle concept. We believe that a degree of modularity and configurability will be required within the interior to accommodate different user requirements. For example, longer journeys of the extra-urban variant may require more luggage space, higher levels of comfort or more access to on-board entertainment facilities than the urban variant.

The interior layout and seating positions could include a combination of front and rear facing seating to better facilitate socialising. There is also the opportunity to consider the facilities that passengers may favour for their journeys. A degree of connectivity to enable work or on-board entertainment is likely to be desirable, particularly on longer journeys.

Addressing passenger anxiety in autonomous vehicles

For some passengers, the prospect of relaxing in a vehicle without any kind of manual driver control might be a daunting one. Our studies have shown that OEMs should anticipate some level of anxiety from passengers, particularly when transitioning from conventional to autonomous vehicles. It is going to be imperative that any autonomous vehicle provides a high level of safety and comfort to reassure nervous passengers. Most of the vehicle’s pro-active safety measures will be hidden from the passenger’s view, but a steel-based structure creates a positive image of safety. Visual cues for reassurance are going to be important to help manage any passenger anxiety.

As with conventional vehicles, autonomous vehicles must go through extensive safety assessments including crash and battery safety testing. The removal of the driver position allows us to explore new vehicle designs which more efficiently use the structure to improve safety performance. The ability to place passengers in non-conventional seating positions within the vehicle creates a safety challenge, but steel innovation allows us to explore the design of Steel E-Motive’s primary vehicle structure and improve on crash and safety load paths. We are exploring vehicle structural improvements, combined with new steel and steel technologies to improve the overall safety of the vehicle concepts.

Passengers also are concerned with safety inside the cabin. The COVID-19 pandemic has placed a new emphasis on the importance of hygiene on public transportation. It will be essential that any vehicle that is used to transport members of the public can be cleaned to a high standard easily and effectively in order to reduce the risk of germ transmission. The modular approach to the Steel E-Motive vehicle interior will help to facilitate hygiene within the vehicle, allowing fleet operators to tailor the vehicle interior for social distancing and to make deep cleaning easier.

Good hygiene will be important to the passenger experience in autonomous vehicles

Passengers are likely to be anxious about hygiene in MaaS vehicles.

Disabled access will be important for the passenger experience in autonomous vehicles

Ramp access and flat floors will be essential to ensuring ease of access

Public transportation is for everyone: considering ease of access in autonomous vehicles

As the MaaS concept continues to expand as a model, it is of paramount importance that these services are available to all members of the public. Therefore, vehicle accessibility needs to be thoroughly considered to ensure that people from all backgrounds will be able to access convenient public transportation when they require it.

For the Steel E-Motive vehicle concepts, we are exploring design solutions to enable safe and comfortable access to and from the vehicle. As the interior configuration of the vehicle can change, this has enabled the consideration of new door mechanisms which can improve access. We are expecting the door opening to be wider and higher than a conventional vehicle with consideration for ramp access. We are also aiming to engineer the vehicles with a completely flat interior floor which will offer improved occupant safety and convenience.

These features, in addition to a configurable interior flexible to passenger needs, will help to ensure that autonomous vehicles can be accessible to all.

Promoting a positive passenger experience in autonomous vehicles

It is essential that any fully autonomous vehicle for MaaS applications promotes a positive passenger experience for consumers. This means that the vehicles and the services they provide must be safe, comfortable, convenient to use and represent good value for money. And this is exactly the kind of solution that the Steel E-Motive program aims to develop as we continue to explore designs for our autonomous vehicle concepts.

Find out more about how the Steel E-Motive vehicle concepts is developing so far.

Neil McGregor
Steel E-motive logo

Neil McGregor

Chief Engineer, Steel E-motive and Ricardo

Subscribe for updates

The Steel E-Motive vehicle concept is still in development. Sign up to be the first to hear about the latest developments from the program.

Developing Safety Structures for Mobility as a Service vehicles

In this blog, Neil McGregor outlines how safety structures are being developed for the Steel E-Motive vehicles using AHSS and innovative vehicle architecture solutions.

Designing future autonomous vehicles for use in a ‘mobility as a service’ model

Transport and the way people use it is changing. In the next 20-years, urban mobility is expected to be transformed by the widespread roll-out of fully autonomous vehicles operating within a ride-hailing, mobility as a service (MaaS) model. This will enable people living in and visiting cities to plan, book, and pay for multiple types of mobility services through a digital channel.

Steel E-Motive announce winners of styling competition

Students from Tecnológico de Monterrey won the Steel E-Motive Styling Competition with their futuristic design for an autonomous vehicle.

Automotive World Webinar Instant Replay: Steel structures for mobility as a service vehicles

Free Automotive World webinar on Steel E-Motive’s progress to develop highly efficient steel structures for mobility as a service vehicles.

E-Mobility Engineering captures Steel E-Motive styling reveal at Stuttgart EV Tech

E-mobility Engineering met with WorldAutoSteel and Ricardo engineers to talk about the Steel E-Motive concepts for mobility as a service vehicles.

Design unveiled for connected steel autonomous vehicle for future sustainable urban mobility

To advance sustainable transportation by factoring whole lifecycle into a vehicle’s development, WorldAutoSteel and Ricardo have designed a fully autonomous Mobility-as-a-Service (MaaS) steel-enabled vehicle inspired by contemporary urban architecture trends and focused on passenger safety and comfort.

Steel E-Motive at Pre-COP 26 Milan

Phil Crowther, Business Strategy & Development Director at Ricardo, will be presenting "Connecting e-vehicles to the city" at The Road to COP26 on 30th September at 1000CEST. He will be presenting Steel E-Motive's product vision to meet urban mobility user needs...

How AHSS is improving high voltage battery design and integration in electric vehicles for MaaS applications

Owain Davies discusses how Advanced High Strength Steel (AHSS) is enabling a greater level of flexibility when making battery design decisions for a safe, comfortable and accessible autonomous vehicle experience.

Life Cycle Assessment: 6 areas designers need to consider when taking an LCA approach to vehicle development

A blog by Russ Balzer, Technical Director for WorldAutoSteel and Dr. Don Malen, College of Engineering at the University of MichiganLife Cycle Assessment (LCA) is a methodology that considers a product’s entire life cycle, from raw material and production...

Steel E-Motive program featured by The Engineer

The Steel E-motive team speak to The Engineer about the role that steel has to play in autonomous mobility services and vehicle concepts.